The selection committee evaluates applications based on the following criteria and guidelines:
| CRITERIA | GRADE | |
| 1 being the lowest | ||
| RELEVANCE AND CONNECTIVITY | 1 to 4 | |
| ||
| QUALITY AND INNOVATION | 1 to 4 | |
| ||
| ADMINISTRATIVE/TECHNICAL QUESTIONS | 1 to 2 | |
| ||
| ADDITIONAL POINTS (OPTIONAL) | 1 or 0 | |
| ||
| TOTAL | MAX 11 |
AFAC's staff conducts a registration and administrative check to screen the received applications and ensure that they comply with AFAC’s grant guidelines and requirements, (for example: if the application is complete, samples have been submitted, the budget is clear, projects fits the call categories, the proposal topic is relevant to AFAC’s mission, etc.) The applications that pass the screening are mailed to the jurors.
Following the administrative check, an independent readers committee will then assess the received proposals and select the applications to be sent to the independent jurors committee.
AFAC selects 3 jurors per category specialized in each discipline. Each juror evaluates all applications according to the evaluation criteria.
AFAC staff collect and analyze the recommendations of each individual juror by ranking the applicants scores and pinpointing discrepancies between the various evaluations. This process ensures productive and focused discussion during the selection committee meetings.
The selection committee, made up of the three jurors for each category, are invited to AFAC’s offices to discuss and select the winning grantees. AFAC will present its analysis of the evaluation grids to guide the discussions. All sessions are moderated by the executive director.
AFAC’s team compiles the final selections of the winning grantees and prepares a report for the Board of Trustees indicating applicant statistics, grantee statistics and selected grantees. Upon board approval, the winners are announced to the press.
Winners are contacted and a grant contract is negotiated and signed with AFAC.